A Very StarKid Retrospective

I think it’s fair to say I’m a serious Team StarKid fan now. 2026 has been a bit of a strange year for me, but one positive I will absolutely take away is that I discovered this wonderful, quirky theatre company and will always cherish the comedic songs and musicals they come up with. I’m a fan for life!

I wanted to indulge my autistic side for this one – I’m going to do a “power ranking” / retrospective of their fifteen major shows (so not their sketch shows or live tours), based on their Soundtrack (“MUSIC“), STORY, Characters (“CHAR“), DESIGN and Humour (“JOKES“). I’ll be giving a score out of ten for each category, and just generally talking about what works and doesn’t in each show.

This is just a long-winded excuse for me to talk about a group of talented people whom I’ve really come to appreciate!

Before we begin, you can check out some of my related blog posts below:

Top 50 StarKid Songs

Every Team StarKid Musical Ranked

“The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals” – Every Song Ranked

“Nerdy Prudes Must Die” – Songs Ranked

Before delving into each individual musical, I want to give a quick history / summary about where StarKid was as a company (to give some extra context for each musical). In the case of “A Very Potter Musical”, the first musical, that means talking about their origins.

Team StarKid was founded at the University of Michigan in 2009 by Darren Criss, Brian Holden, and brothers Nick and Matt Lang. They and their university pals put on a musical parody of Harry Potter, which was a hit on campus. They recorded the show and uploaded it to YouTube so that they could share it with friends.

What they didn’t expect, however, was for “A Very Potter Musical” to go viral. It was a big hit both on-campus and online, and it was the catalyst for all the StarKid musicals that have come after.

“A Very Potter Musical” follows a new, parodied Harry Potter canon where Voldemort infiltrates Hogwarts in Harry’s second year. It’s a tongue-in-cheek retelling of the first film / book, with a few details from “Goblet of Fire” sprinkled in too.

Music and lyrics by Darren Criss and A.J. Holmes. Book by Brian Holden, Matt Lang and Nick Lang.

Best Song: “Granger Danger”
Worst Song: “Cho Chang’s Song”
MVPs: Lauren Lopez (Draco Malfoy) / Joe Walker (Voldemort)
MUSICSTORYCHARDESIGNJOKESTOTALRANK
87757349th

For a university production, “A Very Potter Musical” is surprisingly robust. It’s a little rough around the edges in terms of its staging and design (which is what hurt its score most), and the script doesn’t explore the characters as much as I wanted it to, but otherwise I was really impressed with their first outing.

What stood out to me most was how excellent the music was. Darren Criss and A.J. Holmes are both fully-formed songwriters even in these early years, and songs like “Goin’ Back To Hogwarts”, “To Dance Again” and especially “Granger Danger” are bursting at the seams with charm and energy.

The performances were all solid, the jokes all landed and the references were all smart – there’s something here for Potter fans and normies (such as me) alike. The MVPs have to be Lauren Lopez as Draco Malfoy for the way she rolled around the stage, and Joe Walker as Voldemort for the way he commanded every scene with villainous glee.

I would’ve personally ranked it higher than 9th, but I gave its overall design a 5/10 and that dragged the total score down. This was a low-budget musical with minimal costuming and stage design. Otherwise, it was fantastic!

After the unprecedented success of “A Very Potter Musical”, Team StarKid knew they had to push the boat out for their next project. That same year they wrote and performed “Me And My Dick” – a show about Joey Richter losing his penis. Yep, that’s the plot.

This is definitely the troupe trying to be “more mature” and “show that they’re not just a children’s theatre company”. They certainly succeeded in one of those goals …

Music and lyrics by Darren Criss, A.J. Holmes and Carlos Valdes. Book by Eric Kahn Gale, Brian Holden, Matt Lang and Nick Lang.

Best Song: “Listen To Your Heart”
Worst Song: “There Ain’t Nothin’ Like A Dick”
MVPs: A.J. Holmes (Joey’s Heart) / Jaime Lyn Beatty (Sally)
MUSICSTORYCHARDESIGNJOKESTOTALRANK
545462415th

I’m not going to beat around the bush – “Me And My Dick” is comfortably the worst StarKid show in my eyes. It has the weakest soundtrack, forgettable characters and a shallow story that relies too heavily on childish humour.

And even after all that, the humour and the set design felt sub-par by StarKid’s standards. Pretty much the only prop is the bed! And pretty much the only joke is that penises and vaginas are talking characters!

I’m happy with the fact this ranked 15th – the same as my personal ranking. “Me And My Dick” isn’t a bad show, and I’m sure it has its fans, but I’m not planning on rewatching it any time soon.

Well, apart from the scene-stealing performance that A.J. Holmes gives on “Listen To Your Heart”. I’ve rewatched that half a dozen times by now.

After two successful musicals in 2009, Team StarKid entered 2010 with one goal in mind – make a hilarious sequel to their viral Potter musical. They once again performed to an audience of their peers at the University of Michigan, and they once again found YouTube fame.

“A Very Potter Sequel” is actually a prequel, taking place in Harry Potter’s first year at Hogwarts, and it adapts plot points from “Prisoner of Azkaban” and “Order of the Phoenix”.

Music and lyrics by Darren Criss. Book by Brian Holden, Matt Lang and Nick Lang.

Best Song: “Not Over Yet”
Worst Song: “Let The Games Begin”
MVPs: Joey Richter (Ron Weasley) / Brian Holden (Professor Lupin)
MUSICSTORYCHARDESIGNJOKESTOTALRANK
766663112th

“A Very Potter Sequel” had some big shoes to fill, and above all else it’s yet another fun ride in the Potter universe. This is very much a “more of the same” type of approach, for better or worse.

Sadly, that does mean I naturally compared the two whilst watching “A Very Potter Sequel” … and came to the conclusion that it wasn’t as strong as its predecessor. I found the story quite boring for a start, but this production simply wasn’t as memorable – narratively and musically – as the iconic original.

The highlights are still great – Joey Richter and Brian Holden shine as Ron and Lupin respectively, and songs like “Not Over Yet” and “Days of Summer” are StarKid classics.

With three on-campus musicals under their belt, there came a point where these talented students at the University of Michigan had to graduate. Obviously. They could’ve gone their separate ways, but instead Team StarKid chose to band together and test themselves.

“Starship” was their first musical performed for the dreaded general public. Would people still support them, even those who’d never heard of them before? The answer, as it turned out, was yes.

It’s a parody of “Starship Troopers”, supposedly, but with a Disney twinge to the whole thing. This dichotomy is, as you’d suspect, quite funny.

Music and lyrics by Darren Criss. Book by Brian Holden, Matt Lang, Nick Lang and Joe Walker.

Best Song: “Kick It Up A Notch”
Worst Song: “Hideous Creatures” (but they’re all pretty good)
MVP: Dylan Saunders (Pincer & Tootsie Noodles)
MUSICSTORYCHARDESIGNJOKESTOTALRANK
88896394th

If there’s one thing that immediately jumps out about “Starship” – especially after three on-campus, low-budget musicals – it’s the set design. The costumes, backdrops and puppets are all amazing! They really helped to immerse me in the story.

Speaking of the story, I’ve never seen “Starship Troopers” but I enjoyed how this parody played out. It has compelling characters like Bug and Pincer who ground this silly insect story with genuine, human desires and motivations.

The music is great … but there’s not enough of it. “Kick It Up A Notch” is the best song StarKid have done (so far), and even the “worst” song “Hideous Creatures” was still pretty good. Give me more music in my musical! Having roughly eight songs (or nine if you count the “Kick It Up A Notch” reprise) across an almost three-hour production is borderline unacceptable.

In the end, I think that’s what prevented “Starship” from being an all-timer – its length. Lots of scenes could’ve been cut down, and some of these jokes felt clunky and, again, could’ve been tightened. Aside from that, however, “Starship” is an early high for the theatre troupe – the high scores in most categories meant it finished a whopping 4th overall.

Shout-out to Dylan Saunders – he stole the show as both the evil Pincer and the simple-minded yet loveable Tootsie Noodles. The fact he managed to bring two iconic characters to life – both so different – in the same show is staggering.

StarKid were well and truly cemented both as a media brand and in the YouTube space by the end of 2011 – so much so that they even went on a national tour, called “SPACE Tour”. They performed songs from all four of their musicals up until that point.

In 2012, they put on a show that they’d been cooking up since their university days – a Batman parody. It’s a sort of Adam West / campy version of the DC universe … and, because StarKid couldn’t get the correct legal permissions, they had to put on the production for free every night. Ouch.

Music and lyrics by Nick Gage and Scott Lamps. Book by Matt Lang and Nick Lang.

Best Song: “Dark, Sad, Lonely Knight”
Worst Song: “Robin Sucks”
MVPs: Jeff Blim (Sweet Tooth) / Joe Walker (Batman)
MUSICSTORYCHARDESIGNJOKESTOTALRANK
9566733=10th

Let’s start with a major positive – I love this soundtrack. Nick Gage and Scott Lamps cooked up some of the catchiest, synth-iest songs in StarKid’s whole catalogue. “Dark, Sad, Lonely Knight”, “Rogues Are We” and “Super Friends” are songs that have been stuck in my head for months. Act 2 opener “Robin Sucks” is weirdly a dud but otherwise the rest is gold.

A couple of other stand-outs are Jeff Blim as the villain Sweet Tooth (I love how deranged he is – the energy is infectious!) and Joe Walker as the titular hero (he plays Batman like a spoiled brat and it’s hilarious). The performances are really good across the board, and elevate what are admittedly one-note characters.

Two things hold “Holy Musical B@man!” back. The first, minor thing is that its set design and costuming is minimal – I’d guess they bought these superhero costumes from a Halloween store. The other, much more glaring issue is that I wasn’t a fan of the plot.

It’s a story of how Batman needs to stop being so spoiled and learn to make friends. This would’ve maybe been a fine B-plot if it wasn’t for the fact that the A-plot was random, senseless and lacked oomph – Sweet Tooth does some generically evil things and I lost interest pretty quickly.

StarKid wasted no time at all going on another national tour – the “Apocalyptour” was yet another success … and I imagine it was a much-needed money-maker after putting on a series of free shows across 2012.

After the success of “A Very Potter Musical”, Team StarKid kept getting invited to “LeakyCon” – the biggest annual Harry Potter fan convention. In 2012, however, they decided to make their convention appearance a special occasion.

“A Very Potter Senior Year” was a one-off show performed with next to no rehearsal time, and it closed out the Potter musical trilogy. It adapted aspects of both “Chamber of Secrets” and “The Deathly Hallows” and saw the return of pretty much all of the original cast.

Music and lyrics by Clark Baxtresser, Darren Criss, A.J. Holmes and Pierce Siebers. Book by Brian Holden, Matt Lang and Nick Lang.

Best Song: “Everything Ends”
Worst Song: “Senior Year”
MVPs: A.J. Holmes (Gilderoy Lockhart) / Joey Richter (Ron Weasley)
MUSICSTORYCHARDESIGNJOKESTOTALRANK
78848358th

The absolute worst part about “A Very Potter Senior Year” is how last-minute it all feels. There’s no set design, simple costumes, and the actors themselves have scripts on-stage that they’re reading from. The result feels unprofessional and oftentimes like this show isn’t “canon” to StarKid.

Which is to say that it’s a miracle it works at all. This will surely be a hot take, but I think it has the best story and funniest moments of the Potter trilogy. I loved how they delved more into each character and their inner conflicts, and something about the manic rehearsal energy (and them constantly breaking character) made it way funnier than it had any right to be.

The soundtrack is very hit-or-miss for me. Songs like “Senior Year” and “This School Is Mine” feel painfully underbaked, whereas others like “Sidekick” and especially “Everything Ends” are amongst StarKid’s best songs. In the end, I think the music’s highs outweigh the lows.

All in all, this was a fitting and often emotional ending to StarKid’s Potter trilogy. The high Story and Humour scores meant this even finished as the best-rated musical of that trilogy!

With 2012 – and the Potter trilogy – done and dusted, 2013 begins what I would call the “second chapter” of the StarKid story. They were comfortable creating and performing parody musicals, and so this was an era where the company started taking more risks in their productions.

After a long night joking and riffing about Disney characters – specifically about whether one of the villains could get the “Wicked” treatment – good friends Eric Kahn Gale, Matt Lang and Nick Lang came up with “Twisted”. It’s a parody of “Aladdin” that paints Jafar as the good guy, which is very funny when you consider that he’s one of the most unambiguously evil villains in any Disney movie.

Music and lyrics by A.J. Holmes and Kaley McMahon. Book by Eric Kahn Gale, Matt Lang and Nick Lang.

Best Song: “Twisted”
Worst Song: “Orphaned At Thirty-Three”
MVPs: Dylan Saunders (Jafar) / Joe Walker (Evil Vizier & Prince Achmed)
MUSICSTORYCHARDESIGNJOKESTOTALRANK
1010107946=1st

“Twisted” is widely regarded to be StarKid’s best musical, and I’d happen to agree (as evident by the near-perfect scores across most categories). It’s almost inconceivable how well this show works.

A.J. Holmes created a musical score which teems with life and melancholy, and Kaley McMahon provided the best lyrics to any StarKid show. Songs like “If I Believed”, “No One Remembers Achmed”, “Twisted”, “The Golden Rule” and “Happy Ending” are amongst my favourite StarKid songs.

What sets this show apart from others, at least for me, its the story and characters. It’s such an emotionally affecting tale, filled to the brim with natural and hilarious jokes, and the characters all have more depth than even their original Disney counterparts. Dylan Saunders is exceptional as the lead Jafar, and Joe Walker shines as both the Evil Vizier and the incompetent Prince Achmed.

The stage design is fine. That’s what ultimately prevents “Twisted” from achieving an unbeatable score. It looks a bit cheap, but you can tell it was made with a lot of love.

Team StarKid are a business at the end of the day. Businesses, believe it or not, need money in order to operate. The creative minds behind StarKid came up with an ingenious way to double their money – run two shows at the same time.

“StarKid Summer Season 2014” was a six week extravaganza where the StarKid cast split off into two and alternated shows. Most of the team went to “Ani”, a Star Wars parody about Darth Vader righting some wrongs of his past.

Music and lyrics by Clark Baxtresser and Pierce Siebers. Book by Matt Lang and Nick Lang.

Best Song: “Ani”
Worst Song: “Strike Back”
MVP: Nick Lang (Obi Wan Kenobi & Emperor Palpatine)
MUSICSTORYCHARDESIGNJOKESTOTALRANK
656662914th

The first thing that immediately jumps out about “Ani” is that the band do the singing, not the actors. I didn’t mind this for the opening number (it felt like a cheeky sitcom intro), but every song after that has this uncanny vibe. I want my StarKid performers to sing, not just dance!

Sadly, the soundtrack is one that I’ve mellowed on over time. At first I really liked the synth-heavy, cheesy soundtrack by Clark Baxtresser and Pierce Siebers, but in hindsight it’s all so generic it hurts. Most of these could’ve been written for any musical and nothing would’ve changed.

As for the story? Eh. It’s a by-the-book parody with corny Star Wars jokes throughout. The costumes all look really cheap but I liked the diversity. Most of the characters border on annoying – this has perhaps my least favourite protagonist of any StarKid show. Darth Vader is such a whiny, unfunny brat!

The only saving grace for me (and the reason my Character and Humour scores didn’t dip below a four) was Nick Lang. He’s been the writer-director of pretty much every StarKid project, and he’s starred in a couple of minor roles here and there, but he absolutely steals the show both as Obi Wan and the Emperor. It’s such a shame that the backlash to this musical put him off ever making another acting appearance!

The final placement of “Ani” was 14th, which matches my personal ranking. Nick Lang’s MVP performance(s) is literally the difference-maker between this and “Me And My Dick”.

While most of the team went off to do “Ani”, a small sect of StarKid committed to Jeff Blim’s wacky musical parody about an educational videogame from the 70’s. It’s not hard to see why many thought “Ani” would be the hit whereas “The Trail To Oregon!” would flop – but it ended up being the other way around.

“The Trail To Oregon!” ran concurrently with “Ani” during that StarKid Summer Season. It follows the bumbling Dikrats family as they traverse America to reach a new life in Oregon, all while avoiding the dreaded Dysentery.

Music and lyrics by Jeff Blim and Drew De Four. Book by Jeff Blim, Matt Lang and Nick Lang.

Best Song: “When The World’s At Stake”
Worst Song: “Caulk The Wagon”
MVPs: Joey Richter (McDoon & Most Other Roles) … & The Whole Cast
MUSICSTORYCHARDESIGNJOKESTOTALRANK
6675933=10th

This had a much smaller cast than the other StarKid shows, but that ultimately works in “The Trail To Oregon’s!” favour. Everyone shines here – I especially loved how Joey played every minor character, quick-changes and all. And his Bandit King is one of my favourite StarKid antagonists.

You’ll notice that I ranked most categories quite low, so I’ll just come out and say it – I think this is StarKid’s most overrated show. It’s one of their funniest, which bumps the total score up, but musically and story-wise I found it quite boring. It’s a slow-paced family drama where the ending is just a character farting for five minutes, followed by everyone getting naked in a lake! That’s one of the worst endings to a musical I’ve ever seen!

I had to docks points from the Design score purely on how cobbled-together everything looks. The bare-bones wagon and Joey’s costume changes certainly boost the Humour score (because they’re funny to look at), but they make “The Trail To Oregon!” feel like one of StarKid’s cheapest, least professional shows.

Still, this musical is a fun time. Songs like “When The World’s At Stake” and “Wagon On Fire” are well worth the price of admission.

After putting on two shows in 2014, StarKid took a much-deserved break for 2015 … apart from “A Very StarKid Reunion”. It’s a collection of scenes and songs from all of their musicals up until that point, as well as a sketch from one of their live shows, performed for an audience at the University of Michigan. It’s good. I’d recommend checking it out if you’re itching for more StarKid content (and you’re willing to buy the digital ticket), but otherwise you’re not missing much.

2016 saw the production of “Firebringer”, a story about cavemen and women discovering fire. It was StarKid’s first non-parody (i.e. it’s not in reference to / based on something, as far as I’m aware) since 2009’s “Me and My Dick”. This was an era where StarKid were branching out both creatively and as a brand, and it was exciting to see them dip their toes into more original content.

Music and lyrics by Meredith Stepien and Mark Swiderski. Book by Brian Holden, Matt Lang, Nick Lang and Meredith Stepien.

Best Song: “Climate Change”
Worst Song: “Just A Taste”
MVPs: Lauren Lopez (Zazzalil) / Meredith Stepien (Jamilla)
MUSICSTORYCHARDESIGNJOKESTOTALRANK
86688367th

I’m one of the biggest “Firebringer” defenders, it seems. Sure, its story is a bit weird and formulaic (with a bizarre ending that almost ruins it). Sure, the characters and their relationships can be a bit hit-or-miss (“Just A Taste”, and the surrounding romance subplot, always makes me groan). But my god is this show so fun.

Meredith Stepien and Mark Swiderski created one of the most buoyant, entertaining soundtracks to a StarKid musical. The percussive style works so well given the context, and tracks like “Climate Change” and “We’ve Got Work To Do” are such earworms.

What really elevates the whole thing is Lauren Lopez as Zazzalil. She gives one of my favourite comedic leading performances in StarKid- every joke and line delivery was gold, and her relationship to Meredith’s Jamilla (albeit a little rushed) was super endearing.

And, after a string of quite cheap-looking shows, “Firebringer” has some of the most impressive staging and puppetry I’ve seen from a low-budget show. Everything about this production oozes charm!

StarKid were well and truly cemented in the musical parody fandom, but they hadn’t had a true, viral hit musical since their “Very Potter Musical” days. “We Got Work To Do” was a song from “Firebringer” that made waves, but the musical itself didn’t propel them to musical stardom.

That all changed with the first musical of what I will dub their “third” era. “The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals” is the first of what would become the “Hatchetfield” trilogy – a trio of horror comedies.

The plot is a simple one – a regular guy is slowly engulfed in a musical against his will. But, as you’d suspect, things quickly spiral out of control.

Music and lyrics by Jeff Blim. Book by Matt Lang and Nick Lang.

Best Song: “Show Stoppin Number”
Worst Song: “Not Your Seed”
MVPs: Robert Manion (Professor Hidgens) / Jon Matteson (Paul Matthews)
MUSICSTORYCHARDESIGNJOKESTOTALRANK
99888423rd

It’s worth noting that for the sake of this entry I’m talking about and scoring the original, not the Remount. But both are great in different ways!

“The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals” is StarKid’s most consistent show to date. Jeff Blim’s soundtrack is excellent – especially tracks like “Show Stoppin Number”, “Let It Out” and “Inevitable” – and the story works really well. Music being diegetic to this world sounds like an easy premise but they use it to the fullest.

This is a horror comedy first and foremost, which means that a lot of brutal and oftentimes shocking plot developments are framed in funny ways. This contrast is what makes the show such a wild ride – and its ending is my favourite of any StarKid show.

The MVP award absolutely has to go to Professor Hidgens – played by either Robert Manion in the original or Will Branner in the Remount. This Doc Brown, closeted-musical-loving, eccentric goofball steals the show in every single scene.

One thing that is perhaps quite underrated about the show is its Design. It has a simple set, simple costuming, simple practical effects etc. but it could not have been done any better given the budget. If anything, the cramped and quaint setting made the whole thing even more intense!

So how would I compare it to the 2025 Remount? This original version is funnier, no question. It’s snappier and the whole thing feels more electric. On the other hand, the Remount has better staging and singing, and a higher production value overall. In summary, you can’t go wrong watching either version … so you may as well watch both!

2019 marked the tenth anniversary of StarKid, and to commemorate the occasion the group put on their biggest show yet. In it, they paid homage to all their musicals up until that point. “StarKid Homecoming” is an amazing “best of” show – if you’re a StarKid fan, I’d say it’s required viewing.

As if we weren’t spoiled enough that year, StarKid then produced the second musical of the Hatchetfield trilogy. “Black Friday” is about a group of shoppers who go crazy over an evil doll. And yes, this musical came out before the Labubu craze. Bonkers.

Music and lyrics by Jeff Blim. Book by Matt Lang and Nick Lang.

Best Song: “Feast Or Famine”
Worst Song: “CaliforMIA”
MVPs: Lauren Lopez (Linda Monroe) / Joey Richter (Uncle Wiley)
MUSICSTORYCHARDESIGNJOKESTOTALRANK
576753013th

Yeah … I don’t like this musical that much in hindsight. I didn’t mind it after my first viewing – if anything I appreciated the bold storytelling and new tone – but “Black Friday” sticks out in StarKid’s discography like a sore thumb.

The main issue I have is with the darker, more serious tone. StarKid are a comedy musical group at the end of the day, and it’s much easier to look past the flaws of a comedy show. In a dramatic show, however, I’m much more inclined to point out the cracks – like how the bloated cast of characters and the gloomy ending didn’t do it for me.

I’m sure I’ll catch heat for this, but I think “Black Friday” has both a weak soundtrack and some of the least funny StarKid gags. Songs like “CaliforMIA” sound like they were written in under an hour. Both of Dylan Saunders’ melodramatic solos are underbaked and almost identical. And, like I said before, the overly-serious tone means the jokes often fell flat.

Still, I have to give major credit to StarKid for taking such a creative risk. Even if I personally didn’t vibe with most of it.

Mere days after “Black Friday” released on YouTube, the world went into lockdown. This COVID era was a tough time for all creative companies, but StarKid didn’t take the setback lying down.

They created a lot of online content during this time, the biggest of which being “Nightmare Time”. It’s a series of horror-themed songs in the Hatchetfield universe (starring some new and returning characters), with some dramatic scenes sprinkled in between. Definitely worth checking out if you want more of that Hatchetfield vibe.

Their first show after COVID was “VHS Christmas Carol”, an adaptation of Charles Dickens’ famous festive story. The original musical was very short, clocking in at only 45 minutes (hence why some fans don’t consider it as a fully-fledged StarKid musical), but more recent versions they’ve performed since have had two additional Christmas stories added.

Music and lyrics AND Book by Clark Baxtresser. Talented guy.

Best Song: “Christmas Electricity”
Worst Song: “That Scrooge” (but they’re all pretty good)
MVP: Clark Baxtresser (Narrator)
MUSICSTORYCHARDESIGNJOKESTOTALRANK
99766376th

This might be controversial, but for this entry I’m just going to look at the original, Scrooge-focused musical. The more recent versions that added two more Christmas stories are good but just more of the same.

I’m in the camp that this is one of the best musicals StarKid have ever done. It’s the epitome of short but sweet – every song and story beat hits the mark. It helps that Dicken’s original work was so masterful to begin with, but this adaptation is excellent.

The two things that hold the total score back for “VHS Christmas Carol” is the fact that its set design is minimal (but I love the LED screen in the background) and there’s simply not that many jokes (but Brian Holden as Tiny Tim was hilarious). Still, I can absolutely see myself putting this musical on for every Christmas season in the foreseeable future.

Due to the simple and timely nature of “VHS Christmas Carol”, the cast have performed it multiples times since. The most notable of these was the “Jangle Bell Tour” – the first national tour since lockdown.

It soon came time to produce another “proper”, full-length musical, and there was no better option than to round out the Hatchetfield trilogy. “Nerdy Prudes Must Die” is the story of a bunch of nerds sticking it to their bully … with disastrous, slasher-inspired consequences.

Fun fact – this was the first StarKid musical I ever watched. My “gateway drug”, if you will.

Music and lyrics by Jeff Blim. Book by Matt Lang and Nick Lang.

Best Song: “Bully The Bully”
Worst Song: “Best Of You”
MVPs: Will Branner (Max Jagerman) / Angela Giarratana (Grace Chastity)
MUSICSTORYCHARDESIGNJOKESTOTALRANK
910891046=1st

As this was my first ever StarKid show, I have a huge fondness for “Nerdy Prudes Must Die”. Are my scores too high and am I being too biased? Probably, but this is my retrospective and this is how I feel about this fantastic musical.

This is the funniest StarKid show, hands down. Every joke lands, and the performances – especially from Will Branner and Angela Giarratana – are hilarious. There are so many line deliveries and punchlines that still live in my head rent free.

The soundtrack is also Jeff Blim’s best alongside “The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals”. It’s just hit after hit, with tracks like “Bully The Bully”, “Hatchet Town”, “The Summoning” and the title track setting the tone … but I wasn’t a fan of the finale number “Best Of You”. I thought it was too cheesy.

Which brings me to my dilemma while scoring this musical – does the fact I thought the ending was cheesy diminish the Story score? In the end, I decided no. The plots all wrap up in satisfying ways, and it was an appropriate ending given the high school setting. In other words, I don’t know how they could’ve written this premise any better.

It’s recently been announced that “Nerdy Prudes Must Die” is getting the West End Remount treatment like “The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals”. I’m skeptical to say the least. I don’t know how they could perform or stage this any better … so I guess we’ll have to wait and see!

“Cinderella’s Castle” kickstarts what I would call the final, “present day” era of StarKid. If this and “Tomb Quest” are anything to go by, we may eventually dub this their “fantasy” era.

It’s a gritty twist on the classic Cinderella story with the titular heroin vowing revenge on her evil (monstrous) stepmother. There’s also a dollop of Jim Henson’s “Labyrinth” sprinkled in, too.

Music and lyrics by Jeff Blim. Book by Matt Lang and Nick Lang.

Best Song: “Ash To Ash”
Worst Song: “Last Forever”
MVP: Bryce Charles (Ella Ashmore)
MUSICSTORYCHARDESIGNJOKESTOTALRANK
787106385th

I’ve been quite harsh with my Design scores so far, but that’s because I was saving that perfect ten for “Cinderella’s Castle”. The fantastical costuming, stage design and especially puppetry are staggering. It’s amazing to see how much this little, university-born theatre company has grown!

This story was excellent. Matt and Nick Lang are so good at spinning a tried and tested narrative in a fresh and exciting way, and the revenge angle made this Cinderella tale worth telling. Weirdly, however, I thought the humour was a little off. Maybe it was the high production value – it didn’t pair well with StarKid’s silly, crass humour.

The soundtrack itself is good … but I think the Jeff Blim fatigue was starting to set in by this point. I really liked “Ash To Ash” and “Neon” but the whole package is very cheesy and, dare I say, Jeff Blim-y. Hey, at least he kills it as the glam rock narrator.

Speaking of killing it, I think Bryce Charles gives one of the best StarKid performances. Period. Her Cinderella is instantly likeable, and I felt utterly compelled to watch her succeed in her quest for vengeance.

The good scores in most categories – and the perfect ten in Design – meant “Cinderella’s Castle” finished 5th overall. Slightly higher than I’d personally put it, but still commendable.

Team StarKid’s most recent musical is “Tomb Quest”, a DnD-inspired tale of a bunch of friends reconnecting. I haven’t seen it yet … but I’m sure it’s good! The music was written by Clark Baxtresser, for a start, so I’m expecting great things once it eventually releases on YouTube.

There have also been a couple of major “Remounts” for past musicals – “The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals” was performed in the West End in mid 2026, and “Nerdy Prudes Must Die” is due to perform also in the West End in early 2027. StarKid have really hit the big time – and they absolutely deserve it.

How lucky are we to live in the same era as Team StarKid? This is a group of talented people who genuinely care about their work and about entertaining others. Not only that, they frequently put their full musicals on their YouTube channel for free. If that’s not deserving of the highest praise, I don’t know what is.

So thank you, Team StarKid. Your silly musicals mean a lot to myself and many other fans across the globe. Long may you reign.

Aaaaand that’s my list! You can check out some of my latest blog posts below:

It’s Always Sunny – Season 18 Episodes Ranked

Get out your toe knives, soak your rum hams and dunk on the jabronis – it’s that time of year where we get ten more helpings of Sunny, baby! There have now been eighteen seasons of “It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia”. Eighteen! This record-breaking comedy continues to delight and horrify … but how would I…

Every Ballon d’Or Winner Since 2000 – Ranked

The Ballon d’Or is the most prestigious individual award in football, so I was delighted when Harry Kane – a fellow Englishman – picked up the trophy. He’s had an incredible season for Bayern and so the award was thoroughly deserved … but that got me thinking – has every Ballon d’Or winner deserved the…

Batman’s Villains Ranked

I’ve been in a serious Batman mood over the last two weeks. First I ranked the films, then I ranked the Batman actors, so now it’s time for the big one – I want to rank Batman’s rogues’ gallery. The memorable villains who make this superhero universe so iconic. I can’t rank all of Batman’s…

Leave a Reply